Not all bridges go over the same water

One of the things about music services like Spotify, Apple Music, or YouTube (and if you donโ€™t think of YouTube as a music archive, youโ€™re missing a bet) is how you can look up songs and find covers you never knew existed. Take โ€œBridge Over Troubled Water.โ€

Aretha Franklin – goes right back to her gospel roots. After a quick Aretha and choir intro, we get a two minute piano and Hammond organ duet, followed by Aretha and choir returning, with a building set of accompaniment.

Johnny Cash – this is late Cash. Spare, raspy, you can almost see the whisky and cigs nearby. Fiona Apple comes in about verse two, and does harmonies. Not displeasing โ€” they work โ€” but even I was surprised by the choices she made. (Ask Ulrika about that one.)

Elvis Presley – in an eerie parallel to his career, the first verse is a real surprise. Sparse, clean, clear, restrained. Then, with each succeeding verse, the accompaniment becomes more overbearing, complete with a soprano of the school of what Stan Freberg called โ€œvapor girl.โ€

Roberta Flack – just a woman and her piano. A drum set comes in later.

As you listen to them all, you get to appreciate Art Garfunkelโ€™s original clarity. Sure, his tone is an acquired taste, but everyone else has enunciation problems by comparison. You can always understand Artโ€™s words.

EDIT: Itโ€™s spooky to hear the cast of Gleeโ€™s version, which is a note-for-note copy of Arethaโ€™s. Instrumentation, arrangement, vocal flourishes, the lot. Oh, ok, they cut back on the piano and Hammond thing, but itโ€™s TV โ€” time constraints. But everything else.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *